Helping to Mark the Monarch as Thriving, Not Endangered

Helping to Mark the Monarch as Thriving, Not Endangered
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) is currently in the process of evaluating whether to list the monarch as an endangered species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and is required to decide by December 15, 2020. Photo Credit: Photo by Tinthia Clemant from Pexels

The monarch butterfly population has declined considerably over the last several decades. Reasons for the decline are attributed to reduced breeding habitat, extreme weather and other climatic factors in overwintering habitat, pesticides, and deforestation in Mexico. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) is currently in the process of evaluating whether to list the monarch as an endangered species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and is required to decide by December 15, 2020. Originally the listing deadline was June 2019, but the date was extended to allow USFWS more time to prepare its Species Status Assessment, as well as collect additional data regarding conservation actions.

In the meantime, there have been efforts by numerous groups to develop approaches to help the monarch and prevent a listing. For example, monarchs were added to the Working Lands for Wildlife (WLWF) program, a partnership effort between the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS). Through the WLFW farmers and ranchers can voluntarily work with NRCS on implementing various conservation practices on their working lands and receive regulatory predictability through the FWS for endangered species under the ESA. Or in the case of the monarch, ESA predictability should the monarch be listed. Currently, the monarch WLWF only covers states in the Midwest and southern Great Plains, but the program could be expanded to other areas of the U.S. where the monarch is found.

Another monarch conservation effort recently approved is a nationwide Candidate Conservation Agreement with Assurances (CCAA) where more than 45 companies in the energy and transportation sectors will commit to conservation actions on utility and energy lands in the lower 48 states where monarch butterflies are found.  The CCAA is also a voluntary agreement that provides participating partners regulatory assurances from USFWS should the monarch be listed.

In working through its approval of the CCAA the USFSW considered the needs of farmers and ranchers, given that much of the utility and energy infrastructure in the U.S. occurs on top of, underneath, or adjacent to farm and ranch lands. There is a recognition that farmers and ranchers will be key to the success of the agreement. Additional information and materials will be forthcoming to help farmers and ranchers understand the new CCAA, including how it will be implemented and its impacts for landowners adjacent to lands enrolled in the new CCAA.

Closer to home, the Arizona Farm Bureau is part of the Arizona Monarch Collaborative, which is made up of representatives of organizations and state and federal agencies. The group was formed to help bring attention to the monarch in Arizona and the various ways individuals, municipalities, and industries can help enhance and protect monarch habitat. More information regarding best management practices that can help protect monarchs (and pollinators) can be found at www.azmonarchcollaborative.com.

Why should we care in Arizona? Maps of monarch migration reveal monarchs from both the western and midwestern populations travel through Arizona as they move to and from Mexico. Regardless of whether the monarch is listed or not, Arizonans can take steps now with conservation efforts.